In partnership with

Hey Deal Lifters 👋🔥
Today we’re breaking down one of the craziest business comebacks in modern history.

A startup that:

• was called “the next Amazon”

• burned billions

• nearly went bankrupt

• dropped 98% in stock value

• fought through debt, inflation, interest rates, and chaos

• then pulled a 3,000% recovery

• and is now worth $75B

This is the story of Carvana — and the founder who refused to die.

A masterclass in:

• asymmetric bets

• operational brutality

• viral brand building

• turnaround strategy

• and the undeniable power of founder obsession

Let’s dive in. 🚀

🌱 The Spark: “Buying a Car Sucks. Fix It.”

Ernie Garcia III grew up around cars.

His father, Ernie Garcia Jr., ran DriveTime — a massive used car dealership network with thousands of employees and decades of data.

But young Ernie wasn’t interested in just inheriting the business.

He saw a massive problem hiding in plain sight:

❌ People hate buying cars.

The dealership experience was broken:

• aggressive salespeople

• hours of waiting

• confusing paperwork

• hidden fees

• relentless upsells

• games with financing

Consumers dreaded the process.

But Ernie asked a question nobody else was asking:

“What if buying a car was as easy as buying an iPhone?”

He teamed up with:

• Ryan Keeton (brand/marketing genius)

• Ben Huston (operational + financial mastermind)

Their thesis was wild for 2012:

👉 Buy a used car online

👉 See it in 360°
👉 Finance it instantly
👉 Checkout in 10 minutes
👉 Delivered to your driveway next day

No haggling.
No dealers.
No hidden fees.
No paperwork stacks.

An Amazon-style experience for a $20k purchase.

Absurd. Risky. Ridiculed.

Perfect.

Find customers on Roku this holiday season

Now through the end of the year is prime streaming time on Roku, with viewers spending 3.5 hours each day streaming content and shopping online. Roku Ads Manager simplifies campaign setup, lets you segment audiences, and provides real-time reporting. And, you can test creative variants and run shoppable ads to drive purchases directly on-screen.

Bonus: we’re gifting you $5K in ad credits when you spend your first $5K on Roku Ads Manager. Just sign up and use code GET5K. Terms apply.

Use code GET5K now

🧪 2012 — The MVP Advantage Nobody Talks About

Carvana first operated inside DriveTime as a skunkworks project.

Everyone thinks Carvana was a scrappy startup in a garage.

In reality, they had:

• full access to DriveTime’s refurbishing centers

• inventory sourcing channels

• reconditioning plants

• data on pricing, condition, depreciation

• financing knowledge

• logistics infrastructure

This was their secret weapon.

Carvana could test an online model without building the backend first.

This allowed them to run experiments with:

• delivery times

• financing flows

• pricing algorithms

• photos & 360 render tech

• checkout simplicity

By the time they stepped into the public eye, they had a playbook.

📍 2013 — Atlanta Launch: “Will Anyone Buy a Car Online?”

The team launched in Atlanta.

There was one question everyone asked:

“Will anyone buy a car without seeing it in person?”

Turns out…

YES.

Consumers loved:

• transparency

• speed

• the 7-day return policy

• zero-hassle financing

• no dealership pressure

They were solving a painful problem with a delightful experience.

The flywheel began.

🏢 2015 — The Vending Machine: The Most Genius Marketing Move in Auto History

Carvana built a five-story automated car vending machine in Nashville.

Every traditional car exec laughed.

Every founder understood the marketing brilliance.

It accomplished three things:

🔥 1. VIRALITY

Millions of organic shares.
TV news.
Press coverage across the world.

🔥 2. SIGNALING

“This isn’t a dealership.
This is a tech company.”

🔥 3. TRUST

If you’re storing cars in a robot vending tower…
you must be legit.

Customers loved inserting the giant coin and watching their car descend like a bag of M&Ms.

It was marketing theater done right.

📈 2017 — IPO: The Blitzscale Phase

Carvana went public on the NYSE.

The mission:
Grow at all costs. Dominate the U.S. used-car market.

They:

• burned cash

• raised billions

• built 30+ inspection centers

• hired thousands

• erected vending machines nationwide

• built a logistics network from scratch

• built their 360-imaging technology

• set up their own financing channels

Carvana wasn’t a marketplace.
They were building a vertically integrated national car company, fully online.

A massive gamble.

🚀 2020 — The Pandemic Boom: “Touchless Delivery” Wins

Dealerships closed.
Consumers were stuck at home.
Buying a car online suddenly became normal.

Carvana was ready.

Sales exploded.
Revenues soared.
Stock price jumped from ~$30 to over $360.

They became a $60B+ company overnight.

People called it "Amazon for cars."

But behind the scenes…

A storm was coming.

📉 2022 — The Collapse: -98% and a Debt Crisis

Interest rates skyrocketed.
Used car prices dropped.
Financing got more expensive.
Inventory costs ballooned.
Logistics clogged up.

Carvana’s model depended on:

• cheap capital

• high resale prices

• high demand

• aggressive expansion

When the macro environment flipped, it crushed them.

The stock went from $360 → $3.55.

A legendary implosion.

Every analyst predicted bankruptcy.

Journalists wrote obituaries.
Twitter dunked on them daily.
Short sellers piled on.

Most companies die here.

Carvana didn’t.

🏗️ 2023 — The ADESA Bet: The Move Everyone Thought Was Insane

Carvana announced it was buying ADESA, one of the largest U.S. vehicle auction networks, for $2.2 billion.

People screamed:

• “They’re out of cash!”

• “This is suicidal!”

• “They’re digging their own grave!”

But Ernie’s bet was this:

➝ Control the supply chain = control margins

➝ Control reconditioning = control speed
➝ Control auctions = control inventory quality
➝ Control logistics = crush competitors

It was a bet-the-company risk.

Exactly the kind founders take when they’re all-in.

🔥 2023–2024 — The Turnaround Nobody Saw Coming

Carvana did four things brilliantly:

1️⃣ Massive cost cuts

Tightened operations.
Lean teams.
Better routing.
Better refurb efficiency.

2️⃣ Restructured debt

Negotiated with creditors.
Extended maturities.
Freed up oxygen.

3️⃣ Focused on unit economics

Less “growth at all costs.”
More gross profit per vehicle.
Higher margins.
Better pricing algorithms.

4️⃣ Matched supply to demand cycles

Inventory became smarter.
Reconditioning got faster.
Deliveries got cheaper.

In one of the most shocking financial rebounds in modern history…

Carvana became profitable.
Margins hit record highs.
Free cash flow exploded.

The stock surged over 3,000% from its lows.

💰 2025 — Market Cap Crosses $75B

Carvana is now:

• the largest online car retailer in the world

• a logistics & data powerhouse

• a vertically integrated machine

Every analyst who predicted bankruptcy was wrong.
Every investor who mocked them in 2022 is silent.

Carvana beat the market, the haters, the macro headwinds, and the debt.

This is what founder obsession looks like.

🔍 Why Carvana Won (5 Tactical Lessons)

1️⃣ They solved a painful problem consumers hate

Buying a used car sucks.
Carvana made it fun.

2️⃣ They built full-stack infrastructure (hard but powerful)

Competitors were marketplaces.
Carvana built:

• supply chain

• inspections

• logistics

• delivery

• financing

• data systems

• physical real estate

Full-stack = control + margin + defensibility.

3️⃣ They created iconic branding

The vending machine wasn’t a gimmick —
It was a trust engine.

4️⃣ They bet big when others were scared

The ADESA acquisition was the turning point.

5️⃣ They mastered the “boring stuff”

Logistics.
Debt restructuring.
Inventory management.
Reconditioning.

Execution → turnaround → dominance.

🎤 Founder Psychology: The Real Reason Carvana Survived

Most founders quit when:

• the stock collapses

• the media turns on them

• investors bail

• employees panic

• lawsuits pile up

• competitors surge

Ernie didn’t quit.

He doubled down.

He believed that a collapsed stock price didn’t mean a collapsed company.

He believed operational excellence would win.

He believed consumers wanted a new way to buy cars.

And he believed Carvana was unavoidable — the future of auto retail.

Conviction like that?
That’s how generational companies are built.

Where to Invest $100,000 According to Experts

Investors face a dilemma. Headlines everywhere say tariffs and AI hype are distorting public markets.

Now, the S&P is trading at over 30x earnings—a level historically linked to crashes.

And the Fed is lowering rates, potentially adding fuel to the fire.

Bloomberg asked where experts would personally invest $100,000 for their September edition. One surprising answer? Art.

It’s what billionaires like Bezos, Gates, and the Rockefellers have used to diversify for decades.

Why?

• Contemporary art prices have appreciated 11.2% annually on average

• …And with one of the lowest correlations to stocks of any major asset class (Masterworks data, 1995-2024).

• Ultra-high net worth collectors (>$50M) allocated 25% of their portfolios to art on average. (UBS, 2024)

Thanks to the world’s premiere art investing platform, now anyone can access works by legends like Banksy, Basquiat, and Picasso—without needing millions. Want in? Shares in new offerings can sell quickly but…

My subscribers skip their waitlist*

_{*Past performance is not indicative of future returns. Important Reg A disclosures: masterworks.com/cd.}

🚀 Deal Lift Takeaway

Carvana proves a lesson every founder needs tattooed on their brain:

**Being a tech company isn’t enough.

To win in the real world, you must master the unsexy stuff.**

• warehouses

• logistics

• unit economics

• debt

• supply chain

• physical assets

Carvana nearly died because they ignored these.
They survived because they mastered them.

It’s one of the greatest corporate comebacks of the last decade —
a reminder that:

💡 A company isn’t dead until the founder stops fighting.

And Ernie Garcia?
He never stopped.

9 Amazon Prime Perks You Need to Be Using

Free music/podcasts, access to lightning deals, and try before you buy are just a few of the many perks that Prime has to offer. Make sure you're not missing out, and get the most out of Amazon Prime.